How the Push to Ban Cashless Businesses Protects Unbanked Households and Small Business Owners
BFC Enterprises • August 3, 2025

In July. U.S. Senators John Fetterman (D-PA) and Kevin Cramer (R-ND) introduced the Payment Choice Act in the Senate to preserve payment options for consumers. A companion bill to the House version introduced by Congressmen John Rose (R-TN) and Glenn Ivey (D-MD) earlier this year, this bipartisan legislation ensures customers can use cash as a form of payment and are able to do so without being charged higher prices.

Why Federal lawmakers are pushing to update the 90-year-old Bank Robbery Act


In an opinion piece, published July 24 by Fox News, journalist Ted Jenkin explains why Senators Fetterman and Cramer are 100% right to push to ban cashless stores and why moving towards a fully cashless society doesn’t just inconvenience people – it hurts them. It widens the wealth gap, excludes millions from daily commerce and puts Main Street businesses at a competitive disadvantage.


When Fetterman says, "It’s simple – it’s legal tender. If you accept money, you have to accept all money," he’s not just making a populist statement. He’s standing up for every American who gets punished simply for trying to pay with the money they earned.


Cashless Policies Punish the Working Class


  • 5.9 million U.S. households are unbanked (FDIC).
  • 18.7 million more are underbanked, relying on check cashers, prepaid cards and money orders.
  • 13% of Americans use cash for all or most purchases.
  • Nearly 40% of Americans couldn’t cover a $400 emergency.


When a store refuses cash, it’s essentially telling millions of people – especially seniors, low-income earners and minorities – that their money isn’t welcome. As the Pennsylvania senator put it, "We can’t let stores discriminate against people just because they don’t have a credit card or a smartphone."


Cashless = Classless

This push toward a cashless economy is driven by tech elites who assume everyone has digital access. Aren’t you sick and tired of the guilt tipping button that now asks you for 20 or 25 or 30% tip with a server watching over you to see what you are going to give them. But this isn’t Silicon Valley – it’s America. Here, you should be able to buy lunch or medicine with a few bucks in your pocket.


And for many Americans, cash isn’t optional – it’s essential.


Why It’s Bad for Business

As someone who works with business owners every day and having owned a concrete driveway installation company, I can tell you, going cashless is bad for business. Here's why:


  1. Swipe Fees Eat Margins Every card transaction costs businesses 1.5% to 3.5%. On tight margins, that’s real money – especially in food, retail and service sectors.
  2. Fewer Impulse Buys Studies show people are more thoughtful when using cash. That’s good for consumers – and helps prevent overreliance on credit.
  3. System Outages Kill Sales When the power goes out or internet fails – like during the 2021 Texas storm – only businesses accepting cash could stay open. In emergencies, cash is king.
  4. Customer Loss Many older adults and working-class families still use cash daily. Turning them away is just bad business.


Privacy and Surveillance Concerns

Every digital transaction is tracked. Your location, purchases and habits are cataloged and monetized by Big Tech and banks.


Cash, on the other hand, protects privacy. No monthly statements, no tracking, no algorithms. The more we give up cash, the more control we give away – to institutions that charge fees, track behavior and limit access.


The Federal Fix: A Simple Ban on Refusing Cash

Cities like Philadelphia, San Francisco and New York have already banned cashless-only retail. It’s time to go national.

Fetterman’s proposed federal law would:


  • Require all physical stores to accept U.S. currency.
  • Impose penalties on violators.
  • Allow exceptions for online-only or high-security federal locations.


It’s not about resisting innovation – it’s about ensuring inclusion. Legal tender should mean what it says: legal for all debts, public and private.


Final Thought: Cash Is Economic Freedom

Once we lose cash, we lose a piece of our freedom. We become more dependent on banks, apps and companies that profit off our transactions and control access to our own money.


Fetterman nailed it: "We’re going to keep pushing until every American – regardless of income – can walk into a store and buy what they need with a few bucks in their pocket." He’s right. And if we care about fairness, privacy and keeping Main Street open to all, we need to get behind him.


Because cash isn’t just currency. It’s economic liberty – and it’s worth protecting.


The bipartisan Payment Choice Act is supported by BFC Enterprises and a variety of trade groups including The National ATM Council, ATM Industry Association, American Bankers Association, The Amusement and Music Operators Association (AMOA), Secure Cash & Transport Association and the National Armored Car Association.

By Todd Farber • November 18, 2026
By Todd Farber, CEO, BFC Enterprises A few years ago, I got a call from a bar owner near Busch Stadium on a Friday afternoon. Cardinals fans were in town for a playoff weekend, and a customer had just told him his ATM wasn’t working. He was concerned. He expected fans coming and going before and after the games, with others settling in to watch on the bar’s TVs. He counted on the extra income the ATM brought in too, and we had just put a new sign in the window advertising it. I told him, “Let me see what we can do.” I pulled up our monitoring program, identified the issue and checked where our technicians were working. Within 10–15 minutes, I called him back. One of our technicians was servicing another machine nearby and had the part his ATM might need in the truck. Our tech arrived a little before 5 p.m. and got the ATM back in service. You can imagine the owner’s relief. He had a working ATM for the busy weekend ahead, and I had another reason to be proud of our team. They understood what was at stake for his business and pulled together to take care of him. To me, that’s just one example of the difference a local ATM provider can make. When you call, you aren’t just another open ticket, but instead you reach someone who knows your business and takes responsibility for helping you. We understand that an ATM outage can mean lost income and customers leaving to find cash. You’re counting on us, and we take that personally.
Barber giving a customer a haircut inside a barber shop, illustrating how convenient cash access can
By Todd Farber • October 29, 2026
See how a Chesterfield, MO barber shop used a free ATM to cut credit card fees, offer cash discounts, increase cash tips and earn additional revenue.